The Orchids of the Sikkim-Himalaya - Book Review

Book Review

by Anu Dharmani

Originally published in BellaOnline

Posted by Sys Admin over 4 years ago.

Article Blog   Article Index

The book The Orchids of the Sikkim-Himalaya (Volume VIII of Annals of the Royal Botanic Garden, Calcutta) is written by George King and Robert Pantling. It is a collectible book, written in 1898 when the Indian sub-continent was under British rule. It is an ultimate orchid guide for researchers and hobbyists alike. The book is divided into two sections; first section provides textual information about the orchids found in the tropical areas of Asia. The second section contains about 450 drawing of the orchids mentioned in the first section, with floral details in colour. Though, the copy which I used was borrowed from the departmental library of our Botany Department and it did not have the colour plates.

Pros of the book:
• A near complete book on orchids found growing in tropical regions of the Indian sub-continent as well as in the South East Asian region. Rare, threatened as well as those orchids which are no longer found growing in these areas are also described in detail.
• It provides a detailed taxonomic identification followed by morphological details. Flowering season as well as area of distribution are also mentioned for each orchid.
• Plates are very skillfully drawn and if you can get your hands on the edition with colored plates, then wow! Though I would vouch even for the plain black and white drawings.
• The drawings are drawn to show the actual size, while those orchids which are small or tiny (e.g. Thelasis pygmea) are drawn enlarged to make the structure clearer.

Cons of the book
• It is a large book, difficult to carry on field trips (meant to be carried by dedicated souls or harassed doctorate students only!) and it is expensive. A better option would be to get it from a library as I did.
• The taxonomic details of orchids mentioned in the book needs to be checked, as many of these have been renamed or relocated in the taxonomic table.
• The status of many orchids mentioned in the book has changed over time. As many of the orchids which were easily available at the time when this book was written, are now quite rare.
• The biggest flaw, which I experienced while going through this book, was the separately placed drawings from the detailed explanation. You have to keep flipping back and forth while trying to read and match the orchids with their drawings.

I don't own this book, but I got it issued from the library when ever the need arose. Having said that, my recommendation would be to read this book at least once, you can gain good information on many of the tropical orchids.

Share on Social Media:  
Log in to Add a Comment

New Topics

  1. Rae Walker asked question Name help in category General Discussion
  2. John Small asked question Schomburgkia, species or hybrid in category General Discussion
  3. Robert H. Findlay asked question Help with ID of this Eria sp. in category General Discussion
  4. Osura Mindula Gunasena asked question Help to Identify the Id of this Vanda in category General Discussion
  5. Maricarmen Ferreira asked question Care for Myl Quest Fanguito in category General Discussion

New Comments

  1. Robert H. Findlay commented on topic "Help with ID of this Eria sp." by Robert H. Findlay
  2. Carol Holdren commented on topic "Name help" by Rae Walker
  3. Carol Holdren commented on member plant Dtps. Younghome Little Spirit by Heather A
  4. Sara D commented on member plant Den. Green Mist by Sara D
  5. Sara D commented on member plant Phal. bellina var. Coerulea by Sara D
  6. Sara D commented on member plant Pot. Marie Yellow Bird var. Love Love by Sara D
  7. John Small commented on topic "Lady Bug or dangerous bug" by John Small
  8. Carol Holdren commented on topic "Help to Identify the Id of this Vanda" by Osura Mindula Gunasena
  9. Carol Holdren commented on topic "Care for Myl Quest Fanguito " by Maricarmen Ferreira
  10. Roberto Lizama commented on topic "Help to idenficate this orchid" by Roberto Lizama
  11. Mark Ashworth commented on topic "Orchid species search" by Mark Ashworth
  12. Debbie Chase commented on topic "Head on Shot to be Identified" by Debbie Chase
  13. Carol Holdren commented on member plant Phal. Liu's Cute Angel by Mo Chen
  14. Mo Chen commented on member plant Holc. flavescens by Mo Chen
  15. Carol Holdren commented on topic "Identify Orchid" by Debbie Chase
  16. Nilda Vega commented on member plant Bct. Roman Holiday 'Hamlyn' by Terence Kew
  17. Clint Dalrymple commented on member plant Pnr. graminifolia by Clint Dalrymple
  18. Carol Holdren commented on member plant Rth. Beau's Golden Touch 'Touch of Class' by Robert Rand
  19. Robert H. Findlay commented on member plant B. nodosa 'Remar x Mas Mejor' by John Small
  20. Carol Holdren commented on member plant Phal. buyssoniana by Robert Oceans